Something on Scope of Works and Professionalism A piece of a passing thought. Salam, All praise be to Allah SWT for inspiring me to write this piece… In a pumping station, the only 'mechanical' device would be the pump. Unless the Civil Engineering student also learns Fluid Mechanics as extensively as a Mechanical Engineering student does (I don't know the Civil Engg. syllabus, kindly enlighten me). Only then we can consider that the Civil Engineering graduate to be trained or educated in Fluid Mech and therefore should have the capability of specifying a pump Then again if the Civil Engg. graduate should be able to specify a pump - not only in terms of flowrate and head but also the difference between a horizontal-split casing and a vertical-multi-stage, and the type of impellers, shafts, bearings, mechanical seal and what have you - components of the pump. Then, well - mechanical can do it as good as civil does. Maybe that's not the case. ...